Creator of Knowledge
Information Resources Management Association
Advancing the Concepts & Practices of Information Resources Management in Modern Organizations

Ethics is Not Enough: From Professionalism to the Political Philosophy of Engineering

Ethics is Not Enough: From Professionalism to the Political Philosophy of Engineering
View Sample PDF
Author(s): Carl Mitcham (Colorado School of Mines, USA)
Copyright: 2016
Pages: 33
Source title: Leadership and Personnel Management: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications
Source Author(s)/Editor(s): Information Resources Management Association (USA)
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-4666-9624-2.ch060


View Ethics is Not Enough: From Professionalism to the Political Philosophy of Engineering on the publisher's website for pricing and purchasing information.


This chapter argues for understanding engineering ethics in terms of three principles—but then going beyond ethics to political theory. A simplified prefatory comparison between engineering and science points to the importance of ethics in engineering. Section 1 provides a historico-philosophical overview of engineering ethics in the United States, on the premise that American experience can be generally illuminating. The narrative traces a trajectory of commitments from company loyalty to public responsibility, with the public responsibility promoting public engagement. Section 2 considers three influential American cases that together suggest a duty to public disclosure. Section 3 broadens the analysis through selective reviews of engineering ethics profiles in Germany, The Netherlands, Japan, Chile, and in transnational professional engineering organizations, on the basis of which is articulated a duty not only to avoid harm but also to do good. Section 4, a critical reflection on engineering in the intensive form of research and design, posits a synthesis of the principles of participation, disclosure, and beneficence into a duty plus respicare, to take more into account. A concluding section nevertheless suggests the inadequacy of limiting engineering ethics to ethics. Ethics in engineering like ethics generally implicates political theory. Ethics in the absence of politics demands unrealistic personal heroism; political theory without any foundation in ethics promotes tyranny.

Related Content

Hesham Magd, Siraj Kariyilaparambu Kunjumuhammed. © 2022. 25 pages.
Vimbi Petrus Mahlangu, Mpipo Zipporah Sedio. © 2022. 17 pages.
Siraj Kariyilaparambu Kunjumuhammed, Hesham Magd. © 2022. 13 pages.
Hesham Magd, Henry Jonathan Karyamsetty. © 2022. 19 pages.
Agung Nugroho, Saud Saif Albusaidi. © 2022. 15 pages.
Mohammad FakhrulNizam Mohammad, Rusli Abdullah, Marzanah A. Jabar, Rozi Nor Haizan Nor. © 2022. 29 pages.
Abdelali Kaaouachi, Youssef Hamdani. © 2022. 17 pages.
Body Bottom