IRMA-International.org: Creator of Knowledge
Information Resources Management Association
Advancing the Concepts & Practices of Information Resources Management in Modern Organizations

The Fallacies of MDA for Novice Designers: Overusing Mechanics and Underusing Aesthetics

The Fallacies of MDA for Novice Designers: Overusing Mechanics and Underusing Aesthetics
View Sample PDF
Author(s): Kenneth Chen (Drexel University, USA)
Copyright: 2023
Pages: 16
Source title: Research Anthology on Game Design, Development, Usage, and Social Impact
Source Author(s)/Editor(s): Information Resources Management Association (USA)
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-6684-7589-8.ch058

Purchase

View The Fallacies of MDA for Novice Designers: Overusing Mechanics and Underusing Aesthetics on the publisher's website for pricing and purchasing information.

Abstract

Ever since MDA was publicized by Hunicke, Leblanc, and Zubek in 2004, it has become a building block for game developers and scholars. However, it has also incited several misconceptions that have spread among students and the gaming community. For example, players have overused the term “mechanics,” to the point that it is virtually meaningless. On the other side, the terms “dynamics” and “aesthetics” have been comparatively neglected, despite their value. Building upon our experiences of teaching an undergraduate game design course, we argue that these misconceptions stem from the ways that consumers have misinterpreted the MDA framework. Game educators are not necessarily working with experienced designers: they are working with students who are often more passionate about playing games than making them. Thus, game educators need to target this misconception in order to shed light on preconceived biases.

Related Content

Ricardo Alexandre Peixoto de Queiros, Mário Pinto, Alberto Simões, Carlos Filipe Portela. © 2023. 13 pages.
Preety Khatri. © 2023. 17 pages.
Mehmet Kosa, Ahmet Uysal, P. Erhan Eren. © 2023. 31 pages.
Kaila Goode, Sheri Vasinda. © 2023. 22 pages.
Helena Martins, Artemisa Dores. © 2023. 21 pages.
Ali Ben Yahia, Sihem Ben Saad, Fatma Choura Abida. © 2023. 15 pages.
Baris Atiker. © 2023. 23 pages.
Body Bottom